Best Mature First Love Fanfics
The 13 most-loved mature first love fanfics on AO3, ranked by kudos. First love is the only love with no map, and readers cherish the rawness of characters feeling everything at full volume with no defenses built yet.
Top 13 Mature First Love Fanfics
Ranked by AO3 kudos. Every fic on this list is tagged with first love and rated Mature.
It Was All Just a Game (Rewrite)
by write_me227
If there's one thing that Draco Malfoy yearns for, it's seeing Harry Potter in pain. How that happens, he doesn't care. When Potter's name is pulled out of the Goblet of Fire, Draco sees it as the perfect opportunity to fulfill his greatest desire. Except Saint Potter has luck swimming in his veins.
campfire in your chest
by deanpendragon
Kei realizes in their second year of high school that he's probably been in love with Yamaguchi since they were ten. However hopeless he might be in handling that situation, Kei prays he's at least not as hopeless as Hinata and Kageyama. But he just might be.
The President's Son
by AmeliaBedelia
The man in the suit stepped forward. He bowed deeply, holding his position as he spoke. “Jeon Jungkook,” the agent introduced himself. “It’s an honor to serve you.”Jimin narrowed his eyes, scrutinizing the tall man once he stood back up to his full height. “Jeon Jungkook?”“Yes, sir.”Jimin cringed. “
Cascade
by Avonne
Harry wants to touch, and Draco wants to be touched. If only they could figure it out.
Read All About It
by starlightment
Keith is Altea High’s star athlete. And Lance, a wily reporter for the school newspaper, is crushing hard. The only problem? They’ve never actually met before. So when Lance decides to broadcast his long-hidden feelings in an explicitly romantic exposé, he ends up accidentally sparking a school-wide
Second Chances
by TylerReed
Ilya Rozanov's life takes an unexpected turn when a deadly plane crash in 2021 takes his life, right after a fight with his long-time partner, Shane Hollander. Though instead of the afterlife, Ilya is sent back to December 2008, just before his NHL career began, on the very day that he first met Sh
As If Hands Were Enough (to Hold an Avalanche Off)
by theroyalsavage
Nico di Angelo has been through enough to know life doesn't always work out the way you plan. But fate is a funny thing, and, in Nico's junior year of college, it hands him salvation in the form of freckled cheeks and a smile like the sun.
2 / 13189000
by tide (tothemoon)
Even with all of Tokyo’s new acquaintances, classmates, near-strangers, and neighbors, Haruka and Makoto will choose each other.
Sentinel
by Tovaras
Kaidan’s life has never been easy. BAaT nearly drove him to madness, life after was a struggle, but now… Now he is ready. For whatever life tosses at him. Or so he thinks.
Adventures in Babysitting
by nochick_fics
Sixteen-year-old Roy Mustang has his work cut out for him when he takes a job babysitting the well-known and much-feared local hellions, otherwise known as the Elric brothers.
One for the Road
by sillu
Soul and Maka arrive at their college reunion after five years of radio silence, with still-aching wounds and a once-unbreakable friendship in tatters. After Soul's motorcycle breaks down two thousand miles from home, he and Maka embark on a cross-country road trip from Nevada to the east coast. Wit
The Street Where No One Lives
by Grey_Harbor
The city lights its scattered lamps.And far, far away, the empty street waits faithfully for its two heroes to come home. Saitama POV. Saitama wants to take their relationship a step further.
Lingering Ghosts (finnick odair)
by fawnsangel
"I am the echo of your shadow." In the industrial and bleak corner of Eight, Sophia Violet Grover lived as a Capitol darling, her punishment for surviving the games .She learned to survive by becoming something else: a million layers of not her to keep herself alive. Sophia Violet Grover another nai
More Mature First Love Fics on AO3
Browse the full AO3 archive for mature first love fanfiction. Then read offline with Fanfict Reader.
About This List
This list of 13mature First Love fanfics spans 1,456,824 total words. Kudos range from 7 on the newest entries to 18,435 on the most established. 62% are marked complete — check the status flag before committing to a longfic. The most common rating is Mature (13 of 13 fics).
Recurring tags across this list: First Love · Alternate Universe - College/University · Getting Together · Alternate Universe - Modern Setting · Second Chances.
Read mature first love fanfiction on the go
Fanfict Reader is the best way to browse, search, and read AO3 fanfiction on your iPhone. Download for free and start reading your favorite stories today.