What Does Pulled to Publish (P2P) Mean?
Fandom CultureThe practice of removing a fanfic from the internet, filing off the serial numbers — renaming characters, scrubbing canon details — and publishing it commercially as original fiction.
Pulled to Publish (P2P) in Practice
Pulled-to-publish became a household concept when Fifty Shades of Grey, which began as Twilight fanfiction, became a global bestseller, and a wave of fic-to-published romance followed, especially out of Twilight fandom. The practice sits at fandom's most contested ethical fault line: critics argue it commercializes work built on a community's free feedback and violates the gift-economy spirit, while defenders note that AU fic often shares nothing legally protectable with its source and that writers deserve to profit from their own prose. The phrase 'filing off the serial numbers' is the standard idiom for the conversion process. Either way, readers periodically discover that a published novel matches a vanished fic they once kudosed.
Example usage
"That bestselling romance is pulled-to-publish — fandom old-timers can still name the fic it used to be."
Related Terms
Original Work (AO3)
AO3's fandom category for fiction that isn't based on existing media — wholly original stories posted to the archive. It is one of the largest 'fandoms' on the site.
Definition →
Fourth Wall (Fandom)
The norm of keeping fanworks — especially RPF and shipping content — out of the view of the celebrities and creators they depict. 'Breaking the fourth wall' means fan content reaching its subjects, usually to fandom's horror.
Definition →
AU (Alternate Universe)
Short for Alternate Universe: a story that deliberately changes fundamental facts of the canon setting — the time period, the world's rules, or the characters' circumstances. Coffee shop AUs, no-powers AUs, and modern AUs are classic examples.
Definition →
More Fandom Culture Terms
Read fanfiction on the go
Fanfict Reader is the best way to browse, search, and read AO3 fanfiction on your iPhone. Download for free and start reading your favorite stories today.